Why Marketing ROI is Broken — and How LayerFive Fixes It

Sushil Goel • June 23, 2025

71% of advertising campaigns fail to meet expectations.


96% of digital marketers admit their advertising was a waste of money.


These aren't just disappointing numbers—they reveal something is fundamentally broken with how we measure marketing ROI measurement.


You already know this. Your reports show success, but your CFO questions the numbers. Your campaigns look profitable on paper, but the business results don't match. The average buyer hits 10-20 touchpoints before converting, creating a web of interactions that traditional analytics can't untangle.


The problem gets worse as privacy regulations tighten and third-party cookies disappear. Marketing expert Peter Field calls ROI an "incredibly dangerous metric," arguing it pushes teams toward short-term tactics that hurt long-term growth. How to measure ROI on marketing spend has become the question keeping CMOs awake at night.


Here's the good news.


LayerFive's approach to first-party data collection and omni-channel attribution delivers real results: 42% improvement in marketing ROI, 2.5x higher email and ad engagement rates, and 30% lower customer acquisition costs compared to traditional analytics solutions.


Throughout this article, we'll show you exactly why traditional marketing ROI is broken and how LayerFive's solution finally fixes these problems. No more guessing. No more wasted spend. Just clear, actionable data you can actually trust.


Why traditional marketing ROI is broken


Companies spend over USD 2.10 trillion on media annually. Yet traditional marketing ROI metrics fundamentally misrepresent what these investments actually achieve. The obsession with reducing complex marketing campaigns to a single number creates a dangerously incomplete picture of what drives business results.


ROI oversimplifies complex customer journeys


Traditional ROI calculations ignore how customers actually buy.


Here's what really happens: Someone discovers your brand through a blog post, remembers you weeks later and searches for your company directly, then clicks your PPC ad before converting. Most organizations credit the entire sale to that final PPC click—completely ignoring the blog post that started the relationship.


This oversimplification becomes particularly damaging for B2B companies. Standard attribution models fail to capture marketing's influence on complex deals. Single-touch attribution reduces months of sophisticated marketing work into metrics that ignore how B2B deals actually close.


The problem gets worse as customer journeys span multiple devices. Some customers sync their browsers across devices. Others clear cookies or browse privately to avoid tracking. Piecing together the complete journey becomes nearly impossible with traditional analytics.


You're making budget decisions based on incomplete data.


Short-term focus undermines long-term growth


The fixation on immediate ROI creates a dangerous bias toward short-term tactics at the expense of long-term brand building. Peter Field calls this "incredibly dangerous"—ROI measurement leads to an unhealthy focus on quarterly results rather than sustainable growth.


Short-term ROI gets influenced by external factors like seasonal trends or competitor activities. It's an unreliable indicator of marketing effectiveness. Many organizations prioritize immediate returns because they're easier to measure, even though long-term ROI provides a more complete view of marketing impact.


Digital ads exemplify this tension. You can launch them in a day and generate instant attention, but they're not as sustainable as longer-term initiatives like SEO, content marketing, or organic social growth. Content marketing costs approximately 62% less than traditional tactics while generating three times as many leads.


The irony? Long-term strategies deliver superior results, but they get underfunded because their ROI is harder to measure immediately.


Attribution errors distort performance insights


Without accurate attribution, marketing ROI calculations become fundamentally flawed. 61.5% of digital marketing professionals agree that "investment strategy decisions based on attribution insights generally fail to deliver predicted results".

The disconnect happens because:


  • Most marketers rely on last-click data, giving full credit to the final touchpoint
  • Multi-touch attribution models assign arbitrary percentages to different touchpoints (40% to first click, 40% to last click)
  • Cross-device tracking remains fragmented, with browsers used by multiple people
  • Offline marketing impacts (TV, print, radio) stay disconnected from online conversions


Without machine learning, attribution can be up to 80% inaccurate. This leads to massive waste in marketing budget allocations. 84% of North American brand marketers report facing increased pressure to prove advertising effectiveness.


The result? You're making critical marketing decisions based on fundamentally flawed insights. Wasted ad spend, missed opportunities, and erosion of stakeholder trust follow. Unless you adopt more sophisticated approaches to data collection and attribution, this cycle continues.


The real cost of broken ROI measurement


Poor ROI measurement creates more than just confusing reports. It hits your bottom line hard, creating a cascade of problems that most organizations don't recognize until the damage is done.


Your ad budget is bleeding money


Marketing teams routinely buy ad inventory that doesn't match what they think they're getting. The disconnect comes from flawed measurement and attribution. Studies show marketers waste approximately 21% of their budgets on ineffective channels and campaigns.


The problem? Poor attribution models don't actually measure whether ads cause results. They just connect exposure with sales. This leads you to reward low-quality placements with more ad dollars, creating a cycle of wasted spending.


Without proper tracking, you keep pouring money into channels that look successful on paper but deliver minimal real-world impact. Research shows 40%-60% of digital ad budgets get squandered on bots and low-impact placements. Choose the wrong bidding strategy and you'll see suboptimal returns regardless of your approach.


One marketing expert puts it bluntly: "If you settle for a seductively simple measure such as ROI, you may severely distort the true value that marketing is delivering for your organization". That distortion shows up as real financial losses when budgets flow to underperforming channels.


You're missing your best opportunities


Attribution errors don't just create confusion—they blind you to valuable marketing opportunities. Facebook might claim credit for what Google AdWords actually accomplished. Studies show Facebook misattributes 21% of conversions, compared to Google's 17%.

Consider what happened to Adidas. A technical malfunction stopped them from investing in paid search. Result? No decline in traffic or revenue from SEO. Further analysis revealed they should have been allocating more resources to previously undervalued channels like video content, TV, and outdoor advertising.


When your attribution models are incomplete, you:


  • Miss which marketing channels actually influence conversions
  • Overlook opportunities to optimize high-performing but incorrectly measured channels
  • Keep investing in tactics that contribute little to revenue


Marketing teams make crucial decisions based on fundamentally flawed data. One study notes that "attribution errors are commonplace in PPC conversion analysis because tracking the customer journey across multiple platforms is challenging". The result? Effective channels stay underfunded while ineffective ones consume disproportionate resources.


Your stakeholders are losing trust in marketing


The most damaging cost might be the gradual erosion of stakeholder confidence in marketing data. When marketing ROI reports consistently fail to align with actual business outcomes, people throughout the organization lose faith in your numbers.

This trust deficit creates cascading problems:


First, it widens the gap between marketing and other departments. CEOs focus on hard metrics and profit margins, while CMOs often emphasize softer metrics. When ROI measurements appear unreliable, this disconnect intensifies.


Second, it undermines marketing's strategic position. Without credible ROI measurements, marketing gets viewed as a cost center rather than a revenue generator. As one study notes, "If we cannot prove ROI, we are a cost—not an investment or revenue generator".

Third, it creates a crisis of confidence among employees. Three-quarters of American workers would consider taking a new job, with one-third actively looking. This disengagement stems partly from confusion about what constitutes success when performance metrics seem disconnected from reality.


The World Economic Forum suggests that "Trust as an asset appears inherently intangible and difficult to measure". In reality, measurement is not only possible but essential for demonstrating marketing's true value and rebuilding stakeholder confidence.


Attribution is where everything falls apart


Attribution is the root cause of every marketing ROI problem. Without accurate attribution, you're making million-dollar budget decisions based on fantasy data.


Current attribution models don't just fail—they actively mislead. Here's why.


Single-touch models are marketing fiction


Single-touch attribution models assign 100% of conversion credit to just one touchpoint in the customer journey. These models persist because they're simple and Google Ads made them popular, not because they work.


The reality? The average buyer interacts with almost six touchpoints before purchasing. 73% of customers engage across multiple channels. Single-touch models ignore this complexity entirely.


Consider this scenario: Someone reads your blog post, searches for your brand a week later, clicks your PPC ad, then converts. Last-touch attribution gives the PPC ad full credit. First-touch attribution credits only the blog post. Both completely miss how the customer actually made their decision.


This creates dangerous blind spots. First-touch attribution ignores everything that happens after initial contact. Last-touch attribution discards all the marketing work that built interest and trust. You end up with confirmation bias—the data tells you what you want to hear, not what actually happened.


Online and offline data live in separate worlds


Customer journeys now span digital and physical environments. Omnichannel campaigns deliver 250% higher purchase and engagement rates than single-channel efforts. Yet most attribution systems can't connect the dots.


The challenges are real:


  • Customer journeys happen across multiple devices and offline touchpoints
  • Google, Facebook, and Amazon control 74% of global digital advertising but don't share data
  • 80% of marketers worry about bias in AdTech reporting


Here's a common problem: Someone sees your Facebook ad Monday, visits your website Tuesday, then buys in your physical store Friday. Traditional attribution can't connect these interactions. The Facebook ad gets no credit, your website traffic looks unproductive, and your store sales appear to come from nowhere.


Without connecting online and offline data, you systematically undervalue channels that influence customers days or weeks before they buy.


Slow insights kill campaign performance


Speed matters in marketing measurement. Slow insights don't just waste time—they drain budgets and kill ROI.


Companies that act quickly on data-driven insights are 1.5 times more likely to exceed revenue goals. The problem? Most attribution systems deliver insights too late to matter.


Every campaign has a limited window to capture attention. Wait too long to analyze performance, and you miss opportunities to optimize while the campaign is still running. You're essentially flying blind while burning budget.


Standard cross-channel ROI approaches can't support real-time optimization. They focus on historical data instead of current performance. As one veteran marketer put it: "We're trying to solve tomorrow's problems with yesterday's tools".


Delayed insights put you at a competitive disadvantage. Consumer preferences shift rapidly—slow responses to changing trends leave you looking outdated when adaptation matters most.


The attribution problem isn't just technical. It's strategic. Bad attribution leads to bad decisions, which leads to wasted spend and missed opportunities.


How LayerFive fixes marketing ROI


LayerFive tackles the fundamental problems with marketing ROI measurement head-on. While traditional analytics tools leave you guessing about what actually works, LayerFive delivers concrete solutions to the attribution mess.


Hybrid identity resolution across devices


Most analytics platforms force you to choose: deterministic matching using login data or probabilistic matching based on behavior patterns. LayerFive uses both methods simultaneously. This creates comprehensive identity graphs without sacrificing data quality.


The platform builds unified consumer profiles that connect known and anonymous identifiers across all your data sources. Every touchpoint gets tracked and connected, transforming scattered interactions into coherent customer journeys. You can finally see the complete picture of how customers move between devices and channels.


Companies using LayerFive's technology report a 42% improvement in marketing ROI compared to traditional analytics tools. The platform solves identity challenges that 90% of marketers are now trying to address with AI.


Real-time omnichannel attribution


Traditional platforms deliver insights days after interactions happen—too late to matter. LayerFive provides real-time attribution that lets you adjust campaigns immediately based on current performance.


The omnichannel analytics integrate data from every customer touchpoint, online and offline, creating a unified view of the customer journey. This captures how customers actually behave—moving seamlessly between platforms, devices, and physical locations.


With LayerFive's real-time dashboards, you get immediate visibility into campaign performance instead of waiting for monthly reports. This speed matters. Companies that quickly analyze and act on data are 1.5 times more likely to exceed revenue goals.


First-party data collection without third-party cookies


Third-party cookies are disappearing. LayerFive's first-party data strategy future-proofs your measurement. The platform uses a first-party tagging system that collects richer data directly from your websites while respecting privacy boundaries.


LayerFive can even attribute ad impressions that never got clicked through a patent-pending algorithm that doesn't need third-party data or cookies. You maintain visibility into which channels drive conversions without relying on increasingly restricted tracking methods.


The results are clear:


  • 2.5x higher email and ad engagement rates
  • 30% lower customer acquisition costs
  • Full transparency across paid and organic channels


LayerFive unifies attribution, analytics, and audience activation under one platform powered entirely by first-party data. The platform maintains compliance with GDPR and CCPA throughout this process.


This transforms broken ROI measurement into something you can actually trust. What was once marketing's biggest challenge becomes your greatest opportunity for optimization and growth.


LayerFive's privacy-first approach to data


Privacy regulations are tightening everywhere. GDPR, CCPA, and more coming down the pipeline.


Most marketing teams see this as a roadblock. Another compliance headache to deal with while trying to measure ROI accurately.

LayerFive sees it differently. Privacy protection isn't bolted on as an afterthought—it's built directly into the core architecture. You can measure marketing ROI effectively without compromising consumer trust or breaking regulations.


Built-in GDPR and CCPA compliance


Privacy regulations don't have to kill your marketing measurement.


LayerFive's platform comes with comprehensive compliance mechanisms for GDPR, CCPA, and other regional requirements built in from day one. The platform automatically anonymizes personal information that isn't essential for analytics purposes.


This means you maintain robust marketing ROI measurement capabilities while staying compliant with increasingly strict privacy regulations. LayerFive achieves this through first-party data collection methods that respect user consent preferences across all touchpoints.


No scrambling to retrofit compliance. No wondering if you're breaking rules. It just works.


User-controlled privacy portals


Transparency builds trust.


LayerFive provides customizable privacy portals that give consumers direct control over their data. These self-service interfaces let visitors:


  • View what information has been collected about them
  • Modify consent preferences at any time
  • Request data deletion when desired
  • Download their personal information in portable formats


This level of transparency doesn't just satisfy regulatory requirements—it actively builds consumer confidence. The privacy portals help resolve the tension between thorough marketing ROI measurement and respecting individual privacy rights.


Secure first-party tagging system


Third-party cookies are disappearing. You need a solution that doesn't depend on them.


LayerFive's approach centers on a secure first-party tagging system that eliminates dependence on third-party cookies entirely. This proprietary technology collects data directly from your websites and applications, creating a more accurate and privacy-compliant view of the customer journey.


The first-party tags function within your own domain, passing only anonymized or pseudonymized data for analytics purposes. You maintain the richness of insights needed for accurate marketing ROI measurement while avoiding the privacy pitfalls of traditional third-party tracking.


As third-party cookies continue phasing out across major browsers, LayerFive's approach becomes increasingly valuable. The system creates persistent, privacy-compliant identifiers that work across devices and channels without relying on deprecated tracking technologies.


LayerFive solves the crucial question of why marketing ROI is difficult to measure without sacrificing either analytical power or privacy compliance—a balance that traditional analytics platforms simply cannot achieve.


Real results across different industries


LayerFive works differently depending on your business. Here's how it solves specific marketing ROI problems for different types of companies.


Shopify stores get better retargeting immediately


Shopify's built-in analytics miss too many visitors. LayerFive's Shopify integration fixes this by boosting visitor recognition, which directly increases your retargeting audience size and marketing ROI. Setup takes minutes, not weeks.


The Customer Interaction Insight dashboard shows you exactly which sources and campaigns drive revenue. You can filter by attribution models—first-click, last-click, or view-through. This connects impressions and clicks across channels to actual purchases, which matters most during Black Friday when every insight counts.


Most importantly, you can see which campaigns attract new customers versus re-engaging existing ones. This enables email retargeting that delivers a 36:1 return on investment.


B2B companies track complex account journeys


B2B sales cycles involve multiple stakeholders over months. Traditional analytics can't handle this complexity. LayerFive's B2B solution uses account-based attribution to connect marketing activities to revenue at the account level.


The platform tracks both online and offline interactions across all stakeholders—from C-suite executives to technical evaluators. You can see which content influences different decision-makers throughout the buying process.


The system measures what actually matters in B2B: account engagement scores, pipeline velocity, and influenced pipeline value. You get clear visibility into what works best for winning enterprise accounts, creating alignment between sales and marketing with shared metrics.


Custom solutions for enterprise needs


Some businesses need specialized attribution frameworks. LayerFive's team designs, deploys, and optimizes attribution systems tailored to specific business requirements.


The core technology is LayerFive's identity graph—a system that links disconnected identities into a unified customer view. This solves a fundamental problem: connecting scattered interactions across devices and channels into coherent customer journeys.

Traditional analytics create duplicate profiles when customers use different devices. LayerFive's identity resolution technology detects more visitors and connects data from various platforms. This means better personalization and expanded reach across email, SMS, and social channels—delivering up to 42% improvement in marketing ROI.


Conclusion


Traditional marketing ROI measurement is fundamentally broken. You've seen the evidence throughout this article—complex customer journeys that single-touch models can't handle, attribution errors that waste millions in ad spend, and delayed insights that arrive too late to matter.


Most companies continue making critical budget decisions with flawed data. They pour money into channels that look successful on paper but deliver minimal real impact. Meanwhile, stakeholder trust erodes as reported results fail to match business outcomes.

LayerFive fixes this.


The platform's hybrid identity resolution connects fragmented customer journeys across devices. Real-time attribution lets you optimize campaigns immediately instead of waiting weeks for insights. The first-party data collection system works without third-party cookies, protecting your measurement capabilities as privacy regulations tighten.


Companies using LayerFive see:


  • 42% improvement in marketing ROI
  • 2.5x higher email and ad engagement rates
  • 30% lower customer acquisition costs


These results come from accurate measurement, not guesswork.


Whether you run a Shopify store needing better retargeting, manage complex B2B sales cycles, or need enterprise-scale measurement solutions, LayerFive solves the marketing ROI puzzle that's plagued businesses for years.


Marketing ROI doesn't have to be the "incredibly dangerous metric" Peter Field described. With LayerFive, it becomes what it should be—a reliable indicator that balances short-term performance with long-term growth.


The broken ROI measurement era is over. LayerFive shows you the path forward.


FAQs


Q1. Why is marketing ROI challenging to measure accurately?


Marketing ROI is difficult to measure due to complex customer journeys, attribution errors, and disconnected data sources. Traditional methods often oversimplify the process, ignoring multiple touchpoints and the long-term impact of marketing efforts.


Q2. How can businesses improve their marketing ROI?


To improve marketing ROI, companies can focus on data-driven decision-making, implement real-time attribution models, utilize first-party data collection, and adopt omnichannel analytics to gain a comprehensive view of customer interactions across all touchpoints.


Q3. What are the main challenges in measuring marketing ROI?


Key challenges include accurately assigning costs to specific campaigns, establishing baselines for comparison, tracking long-term effects of marketing efforts, and dealing with attribution complexities in multi-channel customer journeys.


Q4. How does LayerFive address common marketing ROI measurement issues?



LayerFive tackles ROI measurement challenges through hybrid identity resolution across devices, real-time omnichannel attribution, and first-party data collection without relying on third-party cookies. This approach provides more accurate insights and enables immediate campaign optimization.


Q5. What benefits can businesses expect from using LayerFive for marketing ROI measurement?


Companies using LayerFive have reported a 42% improvement in marketing ROI, 2.5x higher email and ad engagement rates, and 30% lower customer acquisition costs. The platform also offers better retargeting capabilities, account-based attribution for B2B companies, and custom data services for enterprise-scale measurement.

You might also like:

Google Pays $23 Million: How a CDP Can Help Prevent Future Breaches
By Ash DSouza January 12, 2023
After a 12-year legal battle, Google has agreed to pay $23 million to settle a class action lawsuit brought by consumers who claimed that the company's search engine shared their queries with advertisers or other third parties without their permission. Originally filed in 2010, the lawsuit alleged that when a Google user clicked on a link in search results, the site shared the search terms entered with third parties, potentially revealing personal information about the searcher. According to the suit, advertisers pay Google to see what search terms led consumers to a particular page.
Online store analytics
By Ash DSouza January 11, 2023
As we head into 2023, retailers will need to be even more agile and responsive to the changing landscape to stay competitive and continue driving growth. This means adapting to shifting consumer preferences, new market conditions, and rising costs. One major challenge facing retailers is the shift toward e-commerce, which has accelerated rapidly during the pandemic. Online sales are projected to reach more than $31 trillion by 2025, taking an increasingly larger slice of total retail sales worldwide. To stay competitive in this environment, retailers need to offer seamless and convenient online shopping experiences and effectively leverage social media and influencer marketing to drive customer acquisition and retention.
Accelerate Your Business with Multi-Touch Attribution
By Ash DSouza December 30, 2022
Multi-touch attribution is analyzing and attributing the credit for a sale or conversion to multiple touchpoints in the customer journey rather than just one touchpoint. This can be particularly useful for e-commerce businesses, as it helps marketers understand the effectiveness of different marketing channels and tactics in driving sales.